Hand Sanitizer: Which is Best for Me? Alcohol-based or Alcohol-free?

“Debates” are a hot topic right now. And like most debates, facts and perspectives sometimes make for contest draws because their applications are not always black and white.  Take hand sanitizer, for instance.  Currently, health organizations are tooting the horn for alcohol-based hand sanitizer, but there are lots of reasons why we should consider the benefits of alcohol-free hand sanitizer:

Benzalkonium chloride (BZK), an active ingredient in some alcohol-free hand sanitizer is deemed eligible by FDA for use in the formulation of healthcare personnel hand rubs. Alcohol-free sanitizers with low concentrations of BZK are relatively non-toxic. In contrast, consumption of alcohol-based sanitizers can lead to acute alcohol poisoning.  https://blog.zogics.com/alcohol-based-vs-alcohol-free-hand-sanitizers/ That’s especially important in school and classroom circumstances.  

A second consideration we should give to alcohol-free hand sanitizer is its low flammability; they pose a low fire hazard. And for organizations adhering to NFPA Life Safety Guidelines, alcohol-free sanitizers may offer a multi-modality solution.http://www.kutol.com/non-alcohol-hand-sanitizer/At Gateway Stations, our free-standing dispensers are fitted with locking caps for confidence whether in use with either alcohol-free or alcohol-based hand sanitizer.

Now let’s talk about the effects of alcohol-free hand sanitizers on surfaces, including our skin!  Alcohol-free BZK hand sanitizer provides extended protection against germs, and they continue to provide protection well after the solution has dried. Wow, the hand sanitizer that keeps on giving!  That’s a huge benefit from the alcohol-based hand sanitizer, whose ability to kill bacteria ends once the product has dried on the skin. https://wjla.com/news/nation-world/exclusive-sanitizer-opposed-by-cdc-kills-coronavirus-surrogate-in-lab-tests. And alcohol-free hand sanitizer solutions do not strip away oils in your skin that retain moisture, and thus protect against increased skin irritation and symptoms of dermatitis. And it doesn’t damage clothing, carpet and other surfaces upon which the residue falls, either. Gateway Stations towers include a drip pad that “catches” excess sanitizer, no matter which style you choose to use.

We’ve compared the “safety” aspects of hand sanitizers, but there are economics considerations as well. Alcohol-free hand sanitizers are less expensive with more applications per gallon. A gallon of either kind of hand sanitizer may cost the same, but you will usually get 2,000 to 3,000 more applications out of the foaming solutions. And adoption of alcohol-free BZK hand sanitizer helps to reduce the strain on the supply chain for the general public and in health-care settings, such as hospitals. No matter which hand sanitizer you choose, Gateway Stations dispensers have large capacity reservoirs, extending the opportunity to buy sanitizer in bulk, and saving you money. https://gatewaystations.com/dispenser-savings

We should not discount the benefit of alcohol-free, benzalkonium chloride hand sanitizers.  Although alcohol-based liquid gels continue to be favored by health organizations, it is not because of BZK-based alcohol-free sanitizer’s lack of effectiveness. The problem is the broad term “alcohol-free” because it can apply to a number of products on the market, making it impossible for agencies like the CDC and WHO to endorse them. The benefits or both alcohol-free and alcohol-based hand sanitizers must be evaluated based on the unique needs of an organization and the people they serve. https://www.ajicjournal.org/article/S0196-6553(19)30811-9/pdf

Gateway Stations’ hand sanitizer dispensers can be fitted with either alcohol-free or alcohol-based solutions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *